He had decided to hand Nate an empty envelope in front of the entire family.

I set it down next to my laptop.

For years I had told myself that Warren’s behavior was just how he was.

He could be generous when he felt like it, difficult when he was tired, and unfair when he thought someone needed reminding of where they stood.

I had come up with excuses for every bit of it.

But I had something else to think about, and it had nothing to do with a graduation gift.

For years now, I had been sending my parents $1,650 a month.