“I remember.”

“You told me to apologize for worrying her.”

Charles stared at the floor.

“When I was seventeen, she went through my phone, found messages from a boy in my chemistry class, and called me disgusting.”

“I remember.”

“You told me not to provoke her.”

His eyes shut.

“When she threw half my clothes onto the lawn because she didn’t like the dress I wore to prom, what did you tell me?”