So I answered for him.

Chapter 12 — An Event That Had Already Happened

“You were seated at a VIP table at Le Cirque, in downtown Richmond,” I said.

“You were eating a steak.

You were drinking a bottle of vintage wine.

And you were singing happy birthday to Serena, at two o’clock in the afternoon, at the very hour I was standing alone in a cemetery watching three caskets — two of them small enough to carry under one arm — lowered into the frozen ground.”

My mother’s voice cut in, climbing high and sharp and indignant.