I also wrote that I would not tolerate insults about myself or anyone else around Clara, and that Preston’s parenting arrangements were separate from Patricia’s wishes.

Patricia responded with a simple thank you.

At their first meeting, she brought a small book with fabric pages rather than a shopping bag of expensive gifts.

She sat in the chair I offered and asked before taking Clara into her arms.

For fifteen minutes, she read the same page because Clara kept grabbing the corner and making a delighted little noise.

When she left, Patricia stood at the door and said, “I’m sorry for how I treated you, Marianne.”