When her friends left, she sat beside Dad on the step and asked whether she could make a wish without blowing out a candle.

“Of course,” he said.

She closed her eyes for a few seconds.

Then she opened them and asked, “Does a wish still work if you tell someone?”

“That depends what kind of wish it is,” he replied.

“I wished everybody would stop being mad.”

Dad looked across the garden at me.

His expression told me he was choosing his words with care.