Ruth followed me into my study with her notebook.

At seven thirty, she had sorted the mortgage notices into one pile, the tuition confirmations into a second, and the business requests into a third.

“These shouldn’t be mixed together,” she said.

“Every one of them came from Daniel.”

“That doesn’t make them the same expense.”

I opened the blue three-ring binder and turned to the section marked household assistance.

A few pages had been tucked in behind the mortgage statements.