That motion was serious and it had a real chance and if it had been granted we would have had a video of a shove and no words at all.

What defeated it is five lines of the access log.

Patricia Ocaña had the camera application on her own telephone.

It was installed on her device on the ninth of February 2024 by me, at her request, at the kitchen table, so that she could see the porch.

She opened it fourteen times between February and September.

And on the eleventh of July 2024 at 2:08 in the afternoon she viewed a live feed from the indoor hall camera for forty-one seconds, to check whether a delivery had been left inside the door.

Which means that on the twelfth of September my wife stood in a hall she knew was recorded, by a device she had personally used, with an application on the telephone that was in her hand.