“The video file started recording at six-fifty-two, thirteen minutes before Elaine called everybody to the table.”

Through the little laptop speakers, Mark’s voice came out clear and flat, telling Beth to sit by the sideboard so he’d have a clear angle across the centerpiece.

“I didn’t hear him say that while I was in the kitchen,” I said.

“No one in the kitchen could have,” Beth said.

“And right after this, Elaine goes out into the hall with him for four minutes before she comes back smiling.”

Beth pushed the laptop lid halfway down and reached into her coat pocket for her phone.