“Nothing so far,” Beth said.

“I’ve known Mark and Aunt Elaine all my life, and I’ve never seen them act like this.”

Beth took her phone out of her jacket pocket, tapped the screen, and checked the recording time in the corner before she spoke again.

“I want to be precise about what I saw,” Beth said.

“What’s on the file?” I asked.

“I started recording before anybody sat down at the table,” Beth said, holding her thumb next to the time bar.

“I leaned my phone against the water pitcher so I could pass plates, and I forgot to stop it until after the cake got cleared.”