We parked under the tall lot light across from Elaine’s brick townhome, and by 7:05 p.m. the four of us stood around her shiny mahogany dining table.

Aunt Carol had backed out at the last minute, leaving Elaine, Mark, Beth, and me bunched around the sideboard.

On the sideboard was a $14 supermarket birthday cake under a clear plastic dome, a single pink candle balanced next to the pile of napkins.

“I took back that bakery cake Mark told me about,” Elaine said, smoothing the white lace tablecloth with both hands.

“At two, a child needs plain vanilla, not heavy buttercream.”