“I stayed up till midnight watching the dinner file,” Beth said, her voice so low it hardly carried across the narrow strip of asphalt between our cars.

“What did you see?” I asked.

Beth tapped the screen twice, checked the recording time in the corner, and tilted the phone toward my open window.

The timestamp in the top corner said six forty-eight, seventeen minutes before the birthday cake had been brought out.

On the tiny screen, Elaine stood by the dining room sideboard while Beth’s phone sat propped against a glass water pitcher on the table.

Elaine leaned toward Mark, her hand on his sleeve, talking in a flat, rushed voice.