One video file popped up on the screen, forty-eight minutes and twelve seconds long.

I entered Beth’s six-digit code and hit the space bar.

The timestamp in the lower right corner showed six-forty-eight in the evening, seventeen minutes before Mark and I had even pulled into Elaine’s driveway.

On the screen, Elaine’s dining room was empty but for Mark.

He stood behind the long oak table holding the printed place cards in his left hand, the pink birthday candle next to the bakery box.

Mark picked up the card with my name and moved it from the side of the table to the chair straight across from Elaine’s seat at the head.