“Beth gave me the passcode to the full recording this morning,” I said.

“Mark didn’t just get a short clip of the cake.

The camera was running for almost fifty minutes.”

Victor plugged the drive into his tower, opened the file, and watched without a word from the place cards at six-forty-eight right through all the dinner chatter.

At seven-thirty-four on the screen, my daughter stretched across the tablecloth toward a silver dessert spoon beside the grocery-store cake.

Elaine bent forward, snapped her fingers an inch from my daughter’s nose, and hit the side of her face with the back of her hand.