Arthur glanced up.

“Keep that one.”

I wrote 9:51 PM and drew a line under the sentence.

Then I played the fourth message again.

Julian said, “The club is just a business expense, Sloane.

You know how this stuff works.” I wrote 9:18 PM and underlined business expense.

After the ninth message, Arthur went into the pantry and came back with an old hole punch.

The black handle had been worn smooth.