The footage was shaky, shot from behind a partly open door — Genevieve filming in secret, in the hallway of my own home.

And then Vivienne’s voice came through the laptop speaker, and it was nothing like the voice I knew.

It was sharp, and cold, and stripped of every soft thing she had ever shown me.

“I warned you to stop interfering, Genevieve.” “My father has a right to know what you’re planning,” my daughter’s voice answered, shaking.

And then there was a sound — a single, ugly, unmistakable sound — and a heavier one after it, something knocked hard against furniture, and a sharp gasp of pain from my daughter.

I will not describe that sound more than to say I have not been able to forget it, and that it was the sound of a woman I loved being hurt by a woman I had been about to marry.