“Everything you’ve told me could be true, and none of it, by itself, would stand up.

What you have is a strong feeling and a great deal of coincidence.

So I am going to ask you to do the hardest thing, which is nothing.

Do not confront him.

Do not tip your hand.

Go home, behave normally, and let us do the quiet work.

Let us run a proper background check, pull what records exist.

If there is something here, we will find it the right way, in a way that holds.