The Girl Who Hid It in Her Shoe
I testified for about ninety minutes on the second day.
The cross-examination lasted forty minutes and was conducted by a very good attorney who was pleasant to me throughout, and it consisted almost entirely of an attempt to establish that I had decided Douglas Sinclair was guilty at 4:14 in the afternoon and had spent the rest of the day arranging facts around it.
He asked me eleven times, in various forms, why I had not simply released two children to their legal father.
And the eleventh time, I said the thing I had not planned to say.
“Because his daughter asked me not to, and I didn’t have any reason not to believe her, and I have never in twenty-nine years been able to work out why a seven-year-old’s account is the only one we treat as automatically unreliable.”
The judge did not strike it.