She held up four fingers, then five, then carefully tucked her thumb away.

“Four,” she announced.

Odessa was there, helping the children decorate paper crowns.

Teddy had stopped by with a small stuffed dog for Piper and an enormous bag of cookies for the adults.

Even Officer Ibarra sent a card through Marisol, a simple note wishing Piper a happy birthday.

During the party, Marisol and I sat beside the window while the children played.

“She still asks sometimes why Dale took her,” Marisol said quietly.