That explained the photograph on his phone.

It did not excuse what happened at the store.

On that Tuesday in March, Marisol had left Piper with Odessa while she worked an extended shift at the care center.

Odessa ran a licensed child-care service out of her home.

According to Marisol, Dale arrived during afternoon pickup, claimed there had been a family emergency, and insisted he was authorized to collect the child.

“Odessa told him to wait,” Marisol said.