“And last November, when I asked if I could come to your family’s Thanksgiving dinner, Vanessa told me the drive downtown would be much too tiring for someone my age,” I went on.

Vanessa opened her mouth to cut in, but I put up one hand, palm out, and she stopped.

“And three months ago, when I lost my footing on the stairs in my building and bruised my hip, I lay on my couch for two whole days waiting for a call back,” I said.

“You were away at the weekend golf retreat with Arthur, and later you told me your phone had died.”

Arthur Sterling took off his gold reading glasses and started polishing them on his cloth napkin, keeping his face turned toward the far wall.