“She never touched a penny of the settlement money you offered her.”

“Look at what she had in her purse,” I said, holding out the brass key.

Paige looked down at the piece of metal lying in my palm.

“She kept my ring in her purse, Paige, right next to a key I’ve never laid eyes on in six years,” I said.

“Where would she get a brass key like that?” Paige asked.

“She didn’t get it at a hardware store,” I said.