J.K. Rowling has made it clear that she will never be able to forgive Daniel Radcliffe or Emma Watson.
The ‘Harry Potter’ series, written by the 58-year-old Rowling, has sold millions of copies worldwide.
Moreover, it has developed into one of the most lucrative film franchises ever.
There has been a lot of controversy surrounding the series in recent years due to the author’s views on s3x and gender.
In a recent statement, Rowling said she would never forgive two of film’s greatest artists.
When Rowling shared an opinion about “those who MENSTRUATE” in 2020, it all started. She seemed annoyed that the word “women” was left out.
“People who menstruate” would be the author’s tweet.
“Those people have probably dated in the past. I need someone to help me. Wumben?
Wimpund? Woomud?
“If the s**t isn’t real, there’s no same-s** appeal,” Rowling said, refusing to retract her claims in the face of widespread outrage. The lived reality of women all over the world is erased if the s**t isn’t real.
“I know and adore trans individuals, but the ability of many people to have meaningful conversations about their lives is lost when the concept of s**t is removed. Speaking the truth is not hate.
In 2022, Rowling will publish “The Ink Black Heart” under the pseudonym Robert Galbraith.
This murder thriller centers on Edie Ledwell, a YouTuber who created a cartoon that drew criticism for being transphobic, ableist, and racist.
“Just finished reading ‘The Ink Black Heart,'” one user tweeted in response to Rowling’s criticism of the new book on X, formerly Twitter.
What do I say to that? Extremely ableist and transphobic. It’s poorly worded. Too wordy. Unbearably long. – Worst series yet.
Another said: “J.K. Rowling is a perfect example of how achieving big money diminishes the humanity that initially led to success.
“Imagine writing a whole sad book about parties because trans-Twitter was mean to you after you were mean to them.”
A number of Harry Potter celebrities have also expressed their disapproval of Rowling’s ideology.
Chris Rankin, who plays Percy Weasley, told the Eastern Daily Press: “I often raise money for the Albert Kennedy Trust and work with groups that are LGBTQ+ focused.
“Many members of my family are members of the community. It plays a significant role in my life and I believe that when I say that, people can infer my loyalty in that regard.”
“It’s important to emphasize that when a trans person says they’re male or female, that’s who they are and that’s how we should treat them,” he continued.
“It’s harmful for them to say otherwise.”
And two of the biggest names in the franchise said the same thing.
In June 2020, Daniel Radcliffe released a statement through The Trevor Project saying he felt compelled to speak out.
It reads: “I understand that some media outlets may try to portray this as a personal dispute between JK Rowling and myself, but that is not the focus at this time, nor is it the point here.
“As someone who has had the privilege of working with The Trevor Project and continues to contribute to it for the past ten years, as well as a human being, I feel obligated to say something at this point, although Jo is undoubtedly to blame. For the direction my life was taking.
Women who are transgender are women. Any suggestion to the contrary goes against the advice of professional health associations who are far more knowledgeable about this than Jo or I, and erases the identity and dignity of transgender people.”
He is “really sorry” that the “Harry Potter” books may have been “tarnished or diminished” for readers, the Woman in Black star continued.
Meanwhile, Emma Watson wrote on social media: “Trans people are who they say they are and deserve to live their lives without being constantly attacked or told they are not who they say they are.”
She followed up her tweet by saying, “I want my trans followers to know that I and many others around the world see, respect, and love you for who you are.”
The Little Women actress is also thought by fans to have poked fun at Rowling during her speech at the 2022 BAFTA Awards.
“Another award is here for Emma Watson,” said Rebel Wilson, host of the event, as she introduced the actress to the stage. We all know she’s a witch, even though she identifies as a feminist.
Watson stated, “I’m here for all witches.”
Rowling responded to criticism of her views.
This Monday, Rowling tweeted about Cass’s research, an impartial investigation into gender identity services for children and adolescents.
According to Mermaids, a charity that helps trans, non-binary, and gender-questioning youth, some of the study’s terminology is open to misunderstanding and could be used to create further barriers to treatment for some trans young people. According to The Guardian.
Rowling, on the other hand, characterized the research as “the most thorough analysis of the medical evidence supporting child transition ever undertaken”.
The author says, “Thousands are complicit, not just health professionals, but celebrity mouthpieces, unquestioning media and cynical corporations.” The author believes that research has shown that “children have been irreversibly affected”.
A Rowling fan said: “I’m just waiting for Dan and Emma to make a very public apology to you… safe in the knowledge that you’ll forgive them…”
However, Rowling is not willing to pardon the two.
Caption: “I’m afraid it’s not safe,” “Celebrities who joined a hard-fought women’s rights movement and used their platforms to encourage underage transitioners can save their apologies for traumatized detransitioners and vulnerable women. Dependent on single-sex spaces.”
Subsequently, supporters supported Radcliffe and Watson. One X user wrote: “Emma Watson and Daniel Radcliffe don’t need forgiveness for being compassionate human beings and they didn’t offer you an apology.”
“What do Emma Watson and Daniel Radcliffe have to apologize to Rowling for?” another commenter asks.
She is the stepmother; they appeared in movies based on her books when they were young.
There is some really weird feudal s***.
The ongoing tension between J.K. Rowling and her former *Harry Potter* co-stars Daniel Radcliffe and Emma Watson began to reflect deeper societal divides around gender and identity. Rowling’s increasingly controversial views on transgender issues have drawn widespread backlash, including from those within the very community that has helped make her books and films a global phenomenon. While she maintains her stance and feels betrayed by those who distanced herself from her, Radcliffe and Watson have stood up for what they see as the fundamental right of trans people to live as their authentic selves, regardless of Rowling’s views.
For many, the tension between Rowling and the *Harry Potter* stars raises uncomfortable questions about loyalty, freedom of speech, and the responsibility public figures have when it comes to social issues. While Rowling has argued that her views are rooted in a desire to protect women’s rights, her critics say her words undermine the dignity and identity of transgender people and, as a result, have increasingly isolated her from some fans who once admired her work.
Radcliffe and Watson’s public statements, on the other hand, reflect a growing recognition of the importance of alliances in the fight for trans rights. Their decision to speak out was not an attack on Rowling personally, but an endorsement of a marginalized group that has often been subjected to harmful stereotypes and denied basic rights.
Ultimately, the dispute serves as a stark reminder of how complex the intersection between personal beliefs, public responsibility, and personal relationships can be. While some fans may still hope for a reconciliation, it seems unlikely that the rift will heal anytime soon. As the conversation about gender identity continues to evolve, both Rowling’s steadfast stance and the trans rights support of Radcliffe, Watson, and many others are likely to remain at the center of this heated debate. Ultimately, it will be up to the individuals involved—and society as a whole—to decide whether forgiveness is possible, or whether the gulf is too deep to be bridged.