Navigating the complex dynamics of family relationships, a mother was faced with a difficult decision—excluding her daughter-in-law Beth from their beloved girls’ outings. These trips, a tradition shared with her three daughters, became a source of joy and bonding. However, bringing Beth into this tight circle began to present difficulties, mainly centered on concerns related to her post-pregnancy weight. walks. These trips, a tradition shared with her three daughters, became a source of joy and bonding. However, bringing Beth into this tight circle began to present difficulties, mainly centered on concerns related to her post-pregnancy weight.
The mother of three daughters said she regularly goes on girls’ trips with her daughters and loves to travel. Without male family members, they would go shopping or engage in other activities. The widow’s son then married a woman named Beth.
When Beth became part of the family, she was invited on girl’s trips. But it was hard for a woman to include Beth after she had a baby because it got in the way of their fun.
A mother described her and her daughters’ day trips as follows: “I have three girls and we still like to take girls’ trips.” My son married a girl named Beth. She hasn’t lost weight and her only child is now eight years old.”
Why did Beth get in the way of their fun?
Beth had not lost her pregnancy weight, so even though she was at a normal weight before giving birth, it was impossible to take her on girls’ trips with her three daughters.
She said walking with Beth required her to stop frequently because of her weight. The woman said she no longer likes her daughter-in-law because of her behavior. She admitted:
“I liked Beth and we often went on trips together. I recently invited the girls to go to the farm to the pumpkin patch and pick apples.
We went, had a great time, and uploaded some photos to Facebook. Beth called and wanted to know why she wasn’t invited.
The woman told readers that she didn’t invite Beth because exploring the huge orchards would require them to stop frequently. She added that Beth preferred to sit on the bench for most of their last visit to the mall.
The woman misled Beth by claiming it was just a family outing when she called to ask why she hadn’t been invited to tour the orchard. The woman was caught by Beth in her lies.
The woman then confessed to Beth that the reason she wasn’t invited was because of her weight and the fact that she kept making them stop, which ruined their girls’ outings because Beth had to sit down.
After expressing disbelief and calling the woman an “idiot,” Beth hung up. The woman’s daughters supported her and said they were sick of Beth ruining their vacation, but the woman’s son then started texting her saying she needed to apologize to Beth.
The mother then asked Reddit users for their unbiased opinion on whether she was wrong to keep her obese daughter-in-law out of family events.
What did Redditors say?
The mother-in-law was told by several that she did the right thing and just needed to make it more clear, although some people believed she was wrong to exclude her daughter-in-law.
Someone commented that it would upset them if someone asked why they weren’t invited to something, especially if they were hoping to do something unique with their girls. It was argued that Beth was pushing too hard and it made sense for the woman to push back.
The individual went on to say that if you don’t get invited somewhere, it’s probably for the wrong reason, so Beth should have accepted her mother-in-law’s kind response instead of calling her a liar.
Someone else suggested that Beth find something that would make it easier for her to fit in with the group, or accept not doing activities that were too physically demanding for her. Additionally, this person hoped that Beth would choose activities that did not require an excessive level of physical fitness when the lady involved her.
The same individual stated that he believed Beth’s attitude, not her physical condition, would prevent her from participating in future family activities. One overweight individual responded that if he knew an activity would require a lot of physical exertion, he would choose not to participate.
The individual acknowledged that Beth may not feel comfortable accepting every offer, but advised her to be cautious when deciding which ones to decline from her mother-in-law.
One person informed the woman that even though she was right to leave Beth out, she should have phrased it differently to save Beth’s confidence. The person suggested framing it as they care about Beth more than anything else.
While some believed that the woman was justified in expelling Beth, others felt that it would not be right for her to be misled as to the reason for her expulsion. The individual specified:
She is sorry because they are moving at different speeds. Her weight may not be the only factor.
One supporter of Beth said her fitness was the problem, not her weight. This person should consider whether they are concerned about Beth’s weight or her fitness, the commenter pointed out, because she could be physically fit and still be overweight.
In the complex dynamics of family relationships, a mother faced the challenge of excluding her daughter-in-law Beth from their beloved girls’ outings. Together with her three daughters, the mother established a tradition of day trips that became a source of joy and bonding. However, Beth’s inclusion began to cause difficulties for the family, particularly due to her post-pregnancy weight.
The mother has been open about her concerns about Beth’s weight, saying it hinders her enjoyment of their activities. She recounted instances where frequent stops during walks were necessary, and Beth’s preference for sitting over active participation became a source of tension. This forced the mother to make the difficult decision to exclude Beth from a recent tour of the orchard, citing the physical demands of the excursion.
The narrative takes a turn when Beth, feeling left out, confronts her mother about the omission. The mother, who chose not to reveal the real reason, initially described the trip as a family affair. However, the truth surfaced during the conversation, leading to Beth’s emotional reaction and accusations.
In search of an unbiased perspective, the mother turned to Reddit, where opinions were divided. Some praised her decision to prioritize the enjoyment of the trips, arguing that Beth’s physical limitations were a valid consideration. Others questioned the mother’s approach, emphasized the importance of clear communication, and suggested alternative ways to handle the situation without causing injury.
Amid the various points of view, the delicate balance between honesty and sensitivity remained at the heart of the matter. The daughter-in-law’s fitness level has been discussed as a potential factor, highlighting the nuances associated with such family dilemmas.
Ultimately, the conclusion of this narrative lies in the continued exploration of how families navigate complex dynamics, communicate effectively, and strive to find a harmonious balance between individual needs and collective traditions.