Discover 44420 Butterfield: A Private Island Retreat Steeped in History
From the moment you approach the island, subtle hints suggest this property holds stories beyond its picturesque exterior. Locals whisper of hidden rooms, decades-old diaries tucked away in quiet nooks, and enigmatic previous owners. At 44420 Butterfield, the allure goes beyond sweeping water views—it’s a home that invites discovery.
Charming 5-Bedroom Home on a Private Island
Welcome to 44420 Butterfield, Alexandria Bay, NY 13607. Built in 1895, this historic detached residence offers 1,126 sq ft of living space on an 8,712 sq ft lot. Combining timeless rustic charm with modern comforts, this rare private island property delivers panoramic lake views and turnkey living, perfect for those seeking a unique retreat.
Inviting and Functional Interior
Step inside to a warm, welcoming living area enhanced by two fireplaces—including a distinctive double-sided fireplace opening onto the exterior deck. This feature brings cozy warmth indoors while creating an intimate atmosphere for outdoor dining, entertaining, or quiet evenings by the lake.
The home’s five bedrooms provide flexible options for family, guests, or a home office. Thoughtful design and rustic accents ensure comfort, practicality, and a seamless connection to the island lifestyle.
Waterfront Access and Boating Features
Private island living comes with exceptional water privileges. This property includes:
A full-size dock with additional dock access
Two boats: a 15-foot Yamaha 40HP motor boat and a 12-foot Nissan 9.5HP motor boat
A 6HP Johnson outboard motor for personal boating
Whether fishing, cruising, or enjoying serene lakeside afternoons, these amenities make waterfront life effortless and enjoyable.
Conclusion
Whether seeking a tranquil summer escape or a full-time island residence, 44420 Butterfield offers a rare combination of history, charm, and panoramic lakefront views.
With flexible living spaces, unique features, and complete boating privileges, this property provides an extraordinary opportunity to own your own private island haven in Alexandria Bay—where every corner may hold a story waiting to be uncovered.