What can be said honestly is this: Moving Robe Woman was in the battle.

She was armed.

She was in the area where Reno’s attack occurred.

Isaiah Dorman died in that area.

The specific details of what happened between them — if anything happened directly between them — cannot be established with certainty from the available evidence.

Historians who have written about this aspect of the battle generally note the uncertainty and distinguish between what can be documented and what is attributed.

The honest account of this aspect of Moving Robe Woman’s story is one that presents the attribution while being clear about its evidentiary basis.