Our two families had celebrated holidays together for almost ten years, and Brian had helped Paul put together the wooden play set in their backyard.

Karen answered the front door in a morning cardigan, and her face sank into a look of deep worry when she saw how I was standing.

“Hannah, what in the world has happened?”

“I need to talk to Paul right now, Karen.”

She stepped aside without another question, seeing the cold resolve in my eyes.

Paul came slowly down the wooden staircase and stopped on the third step, his shoulders sagging in complete defeat.

He didn’t seem surprised to find me standing in his living room among the framed photos of his children.